It depends on the crop. Direct sow root crops, beans, peas, and sweet corn, which dislike being moved. Transplant warm-season crops with long seasons, such as tomatoes, peppers, and eggplant. Many crops, including squash, cucumbers, and most greens, can go either way, and the best choice depends on your season and climate.
Why soil temperature matters
Cold soil slows germination. Cornell Cooperative Extension gives peas as an example: they take about 35 days to germinate in soil at 41°F, about 14 days at 50°F, and about 9 days at 60°F. Slow germination in cold soil gives seed more time to rot or be eaten. Heat-loving crops are more sensitive still, which is why they are usually started indoors, where you control the warmth.
Direct sowing
Pros: It is cheap, avoids transplant shock, and lets roots grow without interruption. You do not need trays, mix, or lights.
Cons: Seed is exposed to weather, birds, pests, and weeds. The top layer must stay moist for germination, and a short season may not give crops time to mature.
Crops to direct sow:
- Root crops: carrots, beets, radishes, parsnips, turnips, and rutabagas. Disturbing the taproot can cause forking or stunting.
- Legumes: beans and peas. Their roots resent being moved.
- Sweet corn. It is best sown in blocks where it is going to grow.
- Okra. It develops a deep taproot, so sow it where it will stay.
- Most cucurbits: squash, cucumbers, pumpkins, and melons. They can be transplanted, but they dislike it, as explained below.
Transplanting
Pros: Transplants give a head start of several weeks in many gardens. They let heat-loving plants skip cold soil. Starting your own transplants also gives you a much wider choice of varieties than a garden center usually stocks.
Cons: It takes more labor and equipment, including trays, seed-starting mix, and lights. Seedlings need hardening off, and transplanting can cause shock if roots are disturbed.
Crops to transplant:
- Warm-season crops: tomatoes, peppers, eggplant, and tomatillos.
- Cabbage family: broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower, and kale. Starts often do better than seed in short seasons.
- Long-season crops: leeks, celery, and onions, which need a long time to mature.
Either way
- Lettuce, spinach, and chard grow well from seed in cool weather. In spring, when the soil is cold and seed is slow to sprout, transplants can help. In late summer, direct sowing for a fall crop often works well.
- Squash and cucumbers can be direct sown in warm soil, or started indoors 2 to 4 weeks before planting out. If you start them indoors, use large pots and move them carefully, because their roots are sensitive.
Harden off transplants
Seedlings grown indoors need 7 to 10 days of hardening off before they go outside. Start with a few hours in a sheltered spot, and extend the time each day. Bring them in on cold nights.
For the seeds to start indoors, see growing a vegetable garden from seed. For carrots, which are always direct sown, see sowing carrot seeds. For transplanted warm-season crops, see growing peppers from seed and growing eggplant from seed.