To save pumpkin or squash seed that grows true, keep same-species plants from crossing. You can do that by planting them far apart or by hand-pollinating and bagging the flowers. After that, the seed-saving steps are simple: scoop, rinse, dry and store.
Why squash cross
Pumpkins and squash belong to the genus Cucurbita, which includes several species. Plants within the same species can cross with each other. Pumpkins and squash from different species generally do not. For example, the common field pumpkin, many summer squash and many acorn squash types are in the same species group, so they can cross if insects carry pollen between them.
Squash plants have separate male and female flowers on the same plant, and insects, especially squash bees and bumblebees, carry the pollen between flowers. A cross does not show up in the fruit you are eating, but it does show up in the seed inside. If you save seed from a fruit that was pollinated by a different variety, the next generation may look or taste different.
Keep it true: distance, timing and bagging
You have two main options.
- Distance. Seed-saving references commonly suggest keeping plants of the same species about half a mile apart. For most backyard gardens, that is hard to do.
- Hand-pollination and bagging. This is the practical option for a small garden. You control the pollen, so the seed comes from the plant you chose.
If you choose hand-pollination, plan for it early. You need to bag the female flowers before they open, which is the evening before, so that no insect can reach them.
Hand-pollinate and bag flowers
- Find flowers that are about to open. Female flowers have a small swollen fruit at the base of the petals. Male flowers have a thin stalk and no fruit.
- Bag the female flowers the evening before. Cover them with a mesh bag or a paper bag secured with a clip or string. Do the same for a few male flowers from the same variety.
- Pollinate by hand the next morning. When the flowers open, remove the bag from a female flower. Pick a male flower, peel back its petals and brush the pollen onto the center of the female flower. Use more than one male flower if you can.
- Tag and rebag. Tie a tag or ribbon to the stem so you know which fruit you pollinated by hand. Rebag the female flower so no other insect can reach it.
Hand-pollination takes some time, but it gives you the most control over the seed.
Pick the fruit and the seeds
Choose a healthy, fully mature fruit from the plant you pollinated. Pick fruit from the variety you want to keep, and avoid fruit from plants that you suspect crossed with other types. A fruit with a hard rind and dry stem is more likely to have mature seed.
Heirloom or open-pollinated varieties usually give seed that grows true. If you are not sure whether a squash or pumpkin is a hybrid, check the seed packet or the grower’s description. Many store-bought jack-o’-lanterns are hybrids, and their seed may not grow like the fruit it came from.
Clean, float, dry and store
Cut the fruit open and scoop the seeds and pulp into a colander or a bowl.
- Rinse. Rinse the seeds under cool or warm water and rub off the stringy pulp.
- Float to sort. Put the seeds in a bowl of water. Good, heavy seeds sink, and empty or immature seeds float. Pour off the floaters.
- Dry. Spread the seeds in a single layer on parchment, wax paper or a clean towel. Avoid regular paper towels, because the seeds can stick. Let them dry in a cool, well-ventilated spot for one to three weeks. Stir them every day so they do not clump or mold.
- Store. When the seeds are completely dry and hard, put them in a paper envelope or paper bag and label it with the variety and year. Avoid plastic, which can trap moisture and cause mold. Keep the container in a cool, dark, dry place.
Pumpkin and squash seed is often good for several years when stored well. Save more seed than you plan to sow, so you have extras if some do not germinate. Pick the largest, plumpest seeds for planting, and see when and how to plant pumpkin seeds for sowing them.
Common questions
Will seed from a store-bought pumpkin grow? It might, but many pumpkins sold for carving are hybrids. If the parent is a hybrid, the seed may give plants that differ from the fruit. For predictable results, use seed from an open-pollinated variety.
Can I save seed from a jack-o’-lantern? You can, but treat it as an experiment. If the pumpkin was grown next to other pumpkins or squash of the same species, it may have crossed. Expect the next generation to vary.
For the general method that applies to other crops, see the complete guide to saving seeds. For the difference between hybrid and open-pollinated seed, see hybrid vs heirloom seeds.