Seed Saving

Hybrid vs Heirloom Seeds: What Happens When You Save Hybrid Seeds

Saved hybrid seed gives unpredictable plants. Learn how to spot hybrids, how heirloom seed differs, and when replanting your seed is allowed.

On this page
  1. What happens when you save hybrid seeds
  2. How to identify hybrid seeds
  3. Heirloom vs non-heirloom seeds
  4. Can you save hybrid seeds?
  5. Can farmers replant seeds?
  6. Is it illegal to save heirloom seeds?
  7. Can I save my pepper seeds for next year?

Whether saved seed will grow true depends mostly on one thing: is the plant an open-pollinated variety, or a hybrid? Open-pollinated plants, including most heirlooms, usually produce seed that grows into plants like the parent. Hybrids usually do not. Saving seed for your own garden is generally allowed, but seed from a hybrid will give you plants that vary, sometimes a lot.

What happens when you save hybrid seeds

A hybrid, often labeled “F1,” is made by crossing two different parent lines. Breeders do this to combine traits such as uniform size, higher yield or disease resistance. The F1 plant shows those traits, but its genes are a mix of two lines.

The seed you save from an F1 plant is the F2 generation. Each seed carries a different shuffle of the parents’ genes, so the offspring can split apart. Some look like one parent line, some look like the other, and many fall somewhere in between. Fruit size, color, flavor, ripening time and disease resistance can all change.

For example, a tomato F1 might produce a uniform crop of medium red fruit. Seed saved from it may grow into plants with smaller fruit, different colors or weaker resistance. You will not know which until the plants grow.

How to identify hybrid seeds

Check the seed packet, the catalog listing or the variety name before you save.

  • Look for “F1” or “hybrid.” Many seed companies print one of these terms on the packet or in the description.
  • Look for “open-pollinated” or “OP.” These descriptions usually mean the seed will come true, as long as the plants are not crossed with other varieties.
  • Do not rely on “heirloom” alone. Heirloom is a common description for older open-pollinated varieties, but it is not a legal category. Read the variety description.
  • If you are not sure, ask the seed company. You can also grow a small test patch. If the plants look very different from each other, the variety is probably a hybrid or an unstable cross.

Heirloom vs non-heirloom seeds

Heirloom seeds are open-pollinated varieties that have been passed down for a long time. A common rule of thumb is that a variety has been grown for 50 years or more, though that is a guideline and not a standard. Seed from these plants usually comes true.

Non-heirloom seeds include hybrids, and they also include some newer open-pollinated varieties. The main trade-offs look like this:

  • Heirlooms often offer distinctive flavors and let you save seed year after year. They may be less uniform in size and ripening, and some have less disease resistance.
  • Hybrids tend to be more uniform, vigorous and disease resistant. They usually cannot be saved to give the same plant the next year.

Neither type is better in every case. Open-pollinated varieties still need isolation or careful planning to stay pure, because insects and wind can carry pollen between nearby plants.

Can you save hybrid seeds?

Yes, you can save seed from a hybrid. The plants that grow from it may be useful, but they will not necessarily match the plant you saved from. If you enjoy experimenting, this can be a fun way to see what the offspring do.

If you want to keep the exact traits of a hybrid, you will need to buy new seed each season. Breeding a stable line from a hybrid is possible but takes many generations of selection, and most home gardeners do not do it.

Can farmers replant seeds?

It depends on the seed. Farmers can generally save and replant seed from open-pollinated, unprotected varieties. Protected varieties are different. Some seed is covered by plant variety protection or by a patent, and some seed comes with a license agreement that forbids saving and replanting.

In the United States, the Supreme Court considered this in Bowman v. Monsanto (2013). A farmer had bought patented Roundup Ready soybeans from a grain elevator, intended for food or feed, and planted the second-generation seed that grew from them. The Court held that the patent was infringed, because the patent covers the seed’s ability to reproduce. Rules differ by country and by variety, so this section is general information, not legal advice.

Is it illegal to save heirloom seeds?

Generally, no. “Heirloom” describes how old a variety is. It does not, by itself, create a legal restriction. What matters is whether the specific variety is protected by a patent or plant variety protection, and whether you are saving seed for your own garden or selling it. Saving seed for your own use is usually allowed. Selling protected seed or breeding a protected variety is where the rules get strict.

Check the terms that came with the seed, and check where you live, before you sell or share seed on a large scale.

Can I save my pepper seeds for next year?

Yes, if the pepper is open-pollinated. Peppers mostly pollinate themselves, but insects can carry pollen between nearby varieties in the same season. A fruit that grew from a crossed flower may give seed that does not match the parent. For the details on keeping peppers true, see how to save pepper seeds from hot and sweet peppers.

If you are growing a hybrid pepper, the seed you save is unlikely to grow true, so buy new seed each year if you want the same plant.

For general information about open-pollinated vegetables, see how to save vegetable seeds, and for the overall method, see the complete guide to saving seeds.

The complete guide to seed saving

The Complete Guide to Saving Seeds
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →