Starting Seeds Indoors

What is the best container to start seeds in?

What is the best container to start seeds in? There is no single winner. Compare trays, cells, pots and household options by seed size and transplant plan.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. What every seed container needs
  3. Seed trays and cell packs
  4. Pots and peat pots
  5. Pellets
  6. Household containers
  7. Self-watering trays
  8. Choosing by seed size and transplant plan
  9. Common mistakes with seed containers
  10. Cleaning and reusing containers
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. Keep going

There is no single best container for starting seeds. For most vegetables, a seed tray or cell pack about 2 inches deep, with drainage holes, is a practical default. The right choice depends on the size of the seed, how long the seedlings will stay in the container, and how you plan to move them into the garden. Whatever you use, drainage, depth and cleanliness matter more than the material.

Short answer

Use a 2-inch-deep tray or cell pack with drainage holes for most seeds. Choose larger pots for seedlings you will keep indoors longer, and pellets or cells when you want to disturb roots as little as possible. Household containers work well if they have drainage holes and are clean.

What every seed container needs

Three things matter most, whatever the material:

  • Drainage. Water must be able to drain out. Without holes, the mix stays wet and roots struggle for air.
  • Depth. About 2 inches is a sensible minimum for most seedlings. Seeds that will be grown longer, such as tomatoes and peppers, often need deeper pots when they are moved on.
  • Cleanliness. Old containers can carry disease. Wash them before reuse and rinse well.

Seed trays and cell packs

Divided trays with individual cells are the most common choice. Each seed gets its own space, and seedlings are easy to label and inspect. Cell sizes range from large cells for bigger seedlings to small cells for many seeds. Smaller cells dry out faster, so they need more attention.

Trays are a good match for most vegetables and flowers. They work well for small seeds, such as lettuce and herbs, and for batches where you want to sow many varieties at once.

Pots and peat pots

Individual pots give roots more room and are useful for seedlings that will stay indoors for longer, such as early tomatoes and peppers. A pot can be moved on without disturbing the roots much.

Peat pots can be planted directly into the ground. They are useful for seedlings that dislike root disturbance. However, they have some drawbacks:

  • They can dry out quickly, especially the exposed rim, which can wick water away from the root ball.
  • Roots may not always grow out through the walls.
  • Peat has sustainability concerns, and many gardeners prefer coir or other alternatives.

If you use peat pots, plant the whole pot below the soil surface so the exposed rim does not dry out the root ball.

Pellets

Compressed peat or coir pellets expand when wet and become a small, self-contained pot. They are simple to use and minimize mess, and you can plant them with the seedling still inside. The same peat concerns apply, and pellets dry out quickly too. Keep them moist and check them often.

Household containers

Many everyday containers work for seeds, as long as they are clean and have drainage holes:

  • Yogurt cups and takeout containers. Poke holes in the base with a nail or awl.
  • Egg cartons. Cut the lid off and sow each cup. Good for small batches.
  • Milk jugs. Cut the top off and punch holes in the base. For using them outdoors over winter, see winter sowing in milk jugs.
  • Clamshell containers with clear lids. Useful as a mini greenhouse. Add holes for drainage and vents in the lid.

Wash all household containers in warm, soapy water and rinse well. Avoid containers that have held chemicals, and check that any container you use for food was food safe.

Self-watering trays

Self-watering trays use a reservoir and a wick to supply water from below. They can reduce the need to water, but they can also keep the mix too wet if you forget to check. Use them with the same caution you would use for bottom watering.

Choosing by seed size and transplant plan

Situation Good options
Small seeds, such as lettuce, herbs or many flowers Seed trays with small cells, or soil blocks
Large seeds, such as squash, beans or peas Pots or pellets, though many are better sown directly outdoors
Tomatoes and peppers you will keep indoors for longer Cells first, then larger pots
Minimal root disturbance at planting Pellets, peat pots planted whole, or cells
Budget or a small number of seeds Clean household containers with drainage holes

Consider the number of seeds too. A large batch fits neatly in a tray. A few seeds of a rare variety may be better in a pot or a yogurt cup.

Common mistakes with seed containers

  • No drainage holes. Water pools and roots rot.
  • Containers too shallow for the crop. Tomatoes and peppers outgrow small cells quickly.
  • Mix that stays soggy. Small containers dry faster at the edges but stay wet at the bottom if they are overwatered.
  • Planting too deep in small cells. Seeds in tight cells can be sown too deep, so check the packet.
  • Leaving seedlings in small cells too long. Pot up once roots appear at the base.
  • Reusing dirty containers. Wash them before reuse, and avoid containers that held diseased plants.

Cleaning and reusing containers

Wash used trays and pots in warm, soapy water, then rinse. A dilute bleach solution can disinfect plastic trays. Rinse well afterwards and let the containers dry in the sun before storing them. Discard containers that are cracked or stained, because they are harder to keep clean.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best container to start seeds in? For most vegetables, a 2-inch-deep tray or cell pack with drainage holes. Use pots or pellets when seedlings will stay longer or need less root disturbance.

What is the most common mistake with seed containers? Usually a container without drainage, or one that stays too wet. Planting too deep and leaving seedlings too long in small cells are also common.

Can I use a yogurt cup? Yes, if you poke drainage holes in the base and wash it well. It is a good choice for a few seeds.

Keep going

The complete guide to starting seeds indoors

Starting Seeds Indoors in Trays and Containers
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →